Kaiko's Q1 market report is now live!

The Aftermath: What Happened to USDC

Stablecoin

CEX

Liquidity

13/03/2023

Welcome to the Data Debrief!

Today, the Kaiko Research team presents a post-mortem of the mass chaos crypto markets experienced amid SVB’s collapse.

  • USDC’s de-peg and the cascading market impact

  • The state of crypto liquidity amid the fiat banking carnage

  • Monday’s market recovery and possible explanations

USDC De-Pegs, Causing Mass Market Chaos

In the hours following Sillicon Valley Bank’s collapse, news emerged that Circle, issuer of the USDC stablecoin, held $3.3bn of reserves in SVB, triggering panic that the stablecoin was no longer fully backed. As of Sunday night, we know that Circle’s reserves are safe, but over the weekend both centralized and decentralized markets descended into chaos. Today, we’ll walk you through what exactly happened.

The Outsized Role of Centralized Exchanges.

USDC’s primary use case is within the DeFi ecosystem, and as such it is relatively illiquid on centralized exchanges. As of last week, it denominated less than 0.5% of total CEX trade volume. However, CEXs played an outsized role in initiating this weekend’s market chaos.

This is because traders had only one thing on their mind amid the uncertainty: where to liquidate their USDC holdings.

Today, there are only 8 active USDC-USD trading pairs on CEXs, which effectively serve as a real-time exchange rate into the dollar. Over the weekend, these trading pairs became the only direct fiat off-ramp amid a halt in redemptions with Circle and Coinbase.

The problem, though, is that these USD pairs are relatively illiquid: daily average trade volume was just $20-$40mn in the first week of March. On Saturday, trade volume for these pairs hit an all time high of $600mn, dominated by Kraken which offers the most liquid USDC-USD pair.

As expected, order books could not support the influx in sell volume, which caused USDC’s exchange rate to nosedive. Before USDC de-pegged, under 20mn in bids sat on USDC-USD order books, which were overwhelmed by hundreds of millions in sell volume.

While USDC-USD trading pairs saw record volumes, the majority of crypto market activity is not actually conducted with the dollar. Most traders use offshore exchanges, which don’t offer a direct USD conversion for USDC, but do offer USDC-USDT pairs. The problem with this is that Binance, the world’s largest exchange, had delisted all USDC trading pairs back in September.

By midday Saturday, Binance finally re-listed the USDC-USDT trading pair, but by then USDC was already trading at a steep discount on less liquid CEXs. Shortly after, trade volume for USDC-USDT pairs hit $9.9bn, an all time high, as traders rotated out of USDC or scooped up USDC at a discount.

Overall, the sells outweighed the buys, causing Tether to trade at a strong premium to both the dollar and USDC.

As Binance re-listed a host of USDC trading pairs, derivatives exchanges also jumped to capitalize on the volatility. Up until this weekend, traders were only able to speculate on the price of USDC on Bybit, which historically had very little activity. Over the weekend, open interest skyrocketed to an all-time high of $256mn. Funding rates remained volatile, oscillating from a negative 0.13% to a positive 1.08% as traders took both short and long bets, but have reverted to neutral as of this morning.

Several other derivative exchanges scrambled to list USDC perpetual over the weekend with a leverage varying from 10x on Bitmex, 20x on OKX, and up to 30x on Binance.

So why did trade activity on CEXs play such a big role in broader market upheaval if USDC isn’t used widely on these exchanges? The quickest answer is that DeFi price feeds for stablecoins don’t provide a true USD exchange rate because you can’t trade fiat currencies on a DEX. This is why many protocols use decentralized price oracles to determine liquidation levels, with data often pulled directly from centralized exchanges.

The answer also lies with how large price display websites such as Coingecko and Coinmarketcap compute their price feeds, which rely heavily on centralized markets. Notably, Curve is not listed on either Coingecko or CMC’s USDC markets page, despite offering one of the most liquid markets.

Overall, illiquid centralized spot markets, the emergence of several USDC derivatives contracts, and viral screenshots from price display websites exacerbated the de-pegging event. Much like a bank run, narrative became reality, which flooded into the DeFi ecosystem.

DeFi Bears the Brunt of USDC De-Peg.

DeFi is practically built on USDC. The stablecoin provides crucial stability to lending protocols and accounts for a significant portion of the reserves of decentralized stablecoins like DAI. Many DeFi protocols were built under the assumption USDC would never de-peg.

Over the weekend, Uniswap and Curve processed record high trade volumes as traders swapped USDC for ETH and other stablecoins, particularly USDT. Since March 10, Curve and Uniswap V3 have facilitated almost identical USDC-USDT volumes, at $5.91bn to $5.96bn, respectively. On Uniswap V3, USDC hit a low of $0.6188 relative to USDT; on Curve it hit $0.6911.

The rush to escape USDC left the Curve 3pool deeply imbalanced, with USDT reaching a low of around 2% of the pool. Today the 3pool holds just under $400mn, almost 95% of which is USDC and DAI, again reflecting the strong demand for USDT.

Lending and borrowing pools were also affected. On March 11, Aave and Compound received more than $2bn in repayments, mostly of USDC, as borrowers were able to repay their loans at a discount because of its depegging.

$400mn total was removed from Compound while $13.1bn was withdrawn from Aave, $11.9bn of which was ETH. Note that this does not mean that TVL dropped by $13.1bn; there were $13.6bn deposits on Aave that day as bots were particularly active on the protocol.

Overall, DeFi markets experienced two days of huge price dislocations that generated countless arbitrage opportunities across the ecosystem, and highlighted the importance of USDC.

Never Miss an Analysis

The State of Market-Wide Liquidity

Now, let’s take a broader look at the market impact of three major bank closures.
A cutoff from USD payment rails means that market makers in the U.S have been pulling liquidity off exchanges, as they determine how they can safely return to offering liquidity in crypto markets.

As a result, U.S exchanges have been hardest hit in terms of liquidity, with Gemini market depth down 74% in March, Coinbase down 50% and Binance.US down 29%. Binance on the other hand is benefiting from it’s more global exposure, with liquidity on the exchange only down 13% so far this month.

When liquidity is down across the board we can see wild price swings in both directions and a lack of liquidity no doubt played a role in the reaction to the bailout news last night. Across the top 10 assets by market cap, crypto market liquidity so far in March was down 52% before the news hit last night that depositors in SVB would be made whole, adding to the volatility of prices in the immediate aftermath.

However, market depth increased by over $125m overnight, or 30%, as price effects played a role in restoring USD liquidity to exchanges.

While price certainly had an impact on the USD liquidity figure on exchanges, a closer look at liquidity at the pair-level shows a large portion of the increase actually came from renewed liquidity for USDC in particular. As it became clear Circle would have access to the $3.3bn they had in SVB as soon as Monday morning, USDC moved closer to its peg and market makers were happy to begin offering liquidity for USDC pairs again.

Using USDC as the base asset, there was a huge spike of over $100mn in extra liquidity offered overnight, with over $60m belonging to the relisted USDC-USDT pair on Binance, while the USDC-USD pair on Kraken saw an injection of $20m in liquidity as well.

Bull Reversal: Binance Recovery Fund

In other news, Binance announced that the remainder of the $1bn Industry Recovery Fund that they have set aside to help salvage some failing crypto companies will be converted from BUSD to BTC, ETH and BNB.

The announcement comes after the recent volatility in the stablecoin space, in which BUSD was implicated due to $250mn of its reserves being held at the now closed Signature Bank. While U.S officials confirmed all depositors will be made whole, Binance obviously sees BTC, ETH and BNB as more secure short term options from both a volatility and liquidity standpoint.

Despite rallying after the news that SVB depositors would be made whole, BTC, ETH and BNB could be due for more positive inflows as it appears the conversion from BUSD by Binance has yet to happen. Our tick trade data shows that sell orders in the last 24 hours are still outweighing buy orders on BUSD pairs on the exchange, with no outsized buy orders.

Considering this conversion looks like it is yet to come, BTC, ETH and BNB look set to potentially outperform the wider market in the near term. So far this month, the three tokens have outperformed a basket of altcoins by 7.5%, down only 2.9% despite recent events. Since the market bottom on March 11th, the three tokens are up 11.5% compared to the altcoins returns of 7.8%.


New DeFi Coverage
Now Live

We are proud to have expanded our DeFi coverage with the launch of Curve v2, Maker, and Balancer v2. Kaiko’s DeFi data allows clients to visualize swaps, mints, burns, and more for the top decentralized protocols. Now covering:

  • Curve v2: trading, and liquidity data for uncorrelated assets

  • Maker: L&B activity + real-world asset events data

  • Balancer v2: trading and liquidity data in smart pools

What Now?

While the full fallout of Silvergate and Signature’s failure is still unclear several points come to mind.

First, the impact on market liquidity will be broad. With Silvergate and now Signature’s closure, crypto market infrastructure has taken a step back as the industry becomes more cut off from the traditional banking system. Real-time payments networks such as Silvergate’s Exchange Network (SEN) and SigNet were crucial for managing overnight and weekends liquidity – facilitating OTC deals, arbitrage between exchanges and stablecoin redemptions outside regular opening hours. With these solutions gone and no alternative for now, fiat on-ramps will likely deteriorate creating perfect conditions for volatile price moves.

Despite improved market wide liquidity via the Fed’s newly created BTFP facility, monetary policy uncertainty has risen which could fuel further risk aversion among institutional traders. Market expectations for the Fed’s terminal rate fell from nearly 6% last week to around 5% as of Monday morning according to U.S. interest rate futures. Expectations for a 50bps rate hike at next week’s Fed meeting went from 40% to zero within days according to the CME FedWatch tool.

Overall, the crypto industry has made it through a momentous market event, and as of Monday morning markets appear to be on steadier ground.

Data Used in this Analysis

  • Derivatives Metrics

    Metrics and analytics products tailored to the cryptocurrency derivatives market.

  • Liquidity Metrics

    The most granular order book data in the industry optimized for quantitative analyis.

  • Trade Volume

    Centralized exchange data sourced from the most liquid venues, covering all traded instruments.

More From Kaiko Research