Bitcoin's Path to Sustainability

ETF Filing Frenzy

ETF

27/01/2025

    Welcome to the Data Debrief!

    Welcome to the Data Debrief! Bitcoin fell below $100K early Monday as Chinese AI app DeepSeek gained popularity, triggering a risk-off market rout. Meanwhile, the U.S. SEC revoked SAB 121, allowing banks to offer crypto custody without accounting for clients’ assets as liabilities, and the U.S. President signed an order to form a crypto regulation group and explore a national Bitcoin reserve. This week we explore:

    • A slew of ETF filings.

    • AI tokens sell-off

    • US exchanges market share

    PLETHORA OF ETF FILINGS

    A lot has happened in the week since Gary Gensler left the US Securities and Exchange Commission. One of the more interesting developments has been the rapid uptick in exchange-traded fund filings tied to digital assets.

    As of our last count there’s now 35 ETF live applications. These range from converting closed-end trusts into spot ETFs to more ambitious filings which would seek to turn newly minted memecoins into spot ETFs.

    Screenshot 2025-01-27 at 15.23.40ProShares, which launched the first US-based BTC futures product in 2021, and Vol Shares have even applied for futures products on SOL and XRP—despite there being no regulated futures markets for these in the US.

    While the leadership at the SEC might have changed, it will still be important to look at the health of the underlying spot market when considering these applications. Below, we charted the average daily 1% market depth—the total of buy and sell orders within 1% of the mid-price—for some of the largest crypto assets. BTC and ETH, which already have regulated spot ETFs in the US, lead significantly, while SOL’s liquidity to date accounts for only 24% of BTC’s liquidity.

    Screenshot 2025-01-24 at 4.10.39 PM
    Market depth is a decent indicator of a markets ability to handle large orders. Lower depth can lead to higher volatility during periods of market pressure. More importantly, extremely low depth might imply a market is at risk of manipulation, as only a few large sellers could move the price.

    If we examine the evolution of market depth over time (chart below), some intriguing trends emerge. Notably, XRP’s depth has increased significantly, surpassing SOL’s depth since January 2025. However, SOL has demonstrated more consistent depth over time. This historical depth performance is an important factor to consider when evaluating a candidate asset for ETFs in the US.

    Screenshot 2025-01-27 at 15.18.27

    Considering these applications are US-based we only took US exchanges into consideration in the above chart. Why does this matter? The SEC will likely be looking for the existence of efficient and stable markets before allowing these products to launch.

    It’s important to caveat that this interpretation is based on the previous SEC’s approvals process and is very likely to change. We’ll get into all of this in more detail on Thursday in our upcoming deep dive on the subject.

    Data Points

    ai tokens sell-off amid market tumult

    Crypto-AI tokens plunged in line with the broader market after the rising popularity of the China-based DeepSeek AI app triggered a rout in tech equities early Monday. AI tokens prices have dropped between 10% and 50% since the start of the year, with Virtual, Artificial Superintelligence Alliance’s FET, Internet Computer Protocol’s ICP, and Worldcoin’s WLD leading the declines.

    Looking at the cumulative volume delta for some of the top AI tokens since January 24, Sam Altman-linked WLD has experienced the most significant selling pressure.

    Screenshot 2025-01-27 at 2.19.02 PM

    Interestingly, Bittensor’s TAO seems to be attracting a different type of investor interest. Despite the overall downturn, the token has seen a positive CVD, suggesting some investors view the dip as an opportunity to buy in.

    Crypto.com dominates us markets

    Crypto.com has taken the U.S. market by storm, with its market share surging from 4% in 2023 to 47% as of last week. In contrast, Kraken and Coinbase have been the biggest losers, with Kraken’s share more than halving from 21% to 9%, and Coinbase’s declining from 45% to 27% over the same period.

    Screenshot 2025-01-24 at 3.00.47 PM

    One of the reasons for this increase is Crypto.com’s lower fees relative to its competitors, making it an appealing choice for U.S. traders. Half of Crypto.com’s trade volume now occurs during U.S. market hours (13:00 to 20:00 UTC), up from 43% a year ago

    Screenshot 2025-01-24 at 3.01.05 PM

    SOL outperforms ETH and BTC

    After a period of underperformance since November, SOL has regained momentum, outperforming both Bitcoin and Ethereum. In January, the SOL/ETH and SOL/BTC ratios climbed sharply, with SOL/ETH reaching an all-time high and BTC/SOL hitting its highest level since March 2024.

    A major catalyst behind this rally was the launch of the TRUMP and MELANIA meme tokens, which marked a significant milestone for Solana’s adoption. Over half of TRUMP and MELANIA buyers were first-time investors in Solana-based altcoins.

    Screenshot 2025-01-24 at 4.10.12 PM

    Despite steady inflows into Ethereum ETFs since November, ETH’s underperformance has raised concerns about the network’s competitiveness. The Ethereum Foundation is facing a leadership crisis, with increasing criticism over its lack of transparency and action, while key community figures have criticized the Ethereum roadmap.

    Crypto market concentration is retreating

    Although there are hundreds of platforms in the crypto space, most trading activity remains concentrated on a handful of major exchanges. This trend accelerated during the 2020–2022 bull run, when large platforms like Binance grew rapidly by scaling up more effectively than smaller competitors.

    However, 2024 seems to have reversed this trend. The top three exchanges now handle 66% of the total trading volume, down from 74% in 2023.

    Screenshot 2025-01-17 at 4.02.38 PM

    The decline in market concentration is mostly happening in offshore markets driven by growing competition between smaller exchanges.

    In the U.S., however, stricter regulations have led to further consolidation. The top five U.S. exchanges expanded their combined market share from 92% in 2023 to 98% in 2024. Binance.US experienced a user exodus following an SEC lawsuit in 2023, while Bittrex ceased its U.S. operations and later filed for bankruptcy.

    Another contributing factor to this trend is that compliance costs tend to burden smaller platforms more heavily. Interestingly, other regulated markets are exhibiting different dynamics. In South Korea, for example, Upbit has lost some of its dominance to rival Bithumb for the first time since 2020.

    Data Used In This Analysis

    Our industry-leading research is the direct result of combining our proprietary data with world-class in-house experts. Bringing the very best of Kaiko’s people and data together, we unlock the unique insights that form the basis for our discoveries and analysis. We believe in doing so, our data speaks for itself, helping both our clients and the wider industry get a better understanding of the crypto ecosystem, and the evolving trends and patterns in motion at a regional and global scale.

    • Trade Data

      Price and transaction volume for centralized exchanges.

    • Market Depth

      All bids and asks on an order book

    • Wallet Data

      All users, all transactions, and all history for blockchain wallets.

    Never Miss An Analysis

    Get our research twice a week, directly to your inbox.

    More From Kaiko Research

    • ETF

      27/01/2025 Data Debrief

      ETF Filing Frenzy

      Bitcoin fell below $100K early Monday as Chinese AI app DeepSeek gained popularity, triggering a risk-off market rout. Meanwhile, the U.S. SEC revoked SAB 121, allowing banks to offer crypto custody without accounting for clients’ assets as liabilities, and the U.S. President signed an order to form a crypto regulation group and explore a national Bitcoin reserve

    • Memecoins

      20/01/2025 Data Debrief

      Trump takes over memecoins

      Bitcoin and several altcoins hit an all-time high as markets anticipate a flurry of executive orders following President-elect Donald Trump’s inauguration today.

    • Bitcoin

      13/01/2025 Data Debrief

      Life after BTC ETFs

      Bitcoin closed the week lower as risk assets tumbled on hotter than expected US jobs report, with prices now nearing a two-month low. In other news, the US Department of Justice approved to sell $6.5bn BTC adding to the risk-off mood.

    • Stablecoin

      06/01/2025 Data Debrief

      Rising interest in Ethena amid Aave, USDtb launches

      Happy New Year, Bonne Année, Gutes Neues Jahr, and all the rest! We’re back from our holiday hiatus just as BTC once again approaches $100k. While the past few days have been relatively quiet, expect increased activity this week with Congress set to ratify the US election results and the first full week of trading since mid-December.